James Trafford’s ambition of becoming Manchester City’s long-term No.1 goalkeeper has been cast into doubt after Pep Guardiola admitted he could not predict whether the 22-year-old will eventually take the starting role.
The England international returned to the Etihad Stadium this summer following a strong spell with Burnley, where he played a crucial role in their promotion back to the Premier League. Trafford’s development has also been recognised at international level, having earned a place in Gareth Southgate’s squad, although he continues to operate as understudy to Jordan Pickford.
Donnarumma arrival changes the picture
Trafford’s path to first-team football was disrupted on transfer deadline day when City signed Gianluigi Donnarumma from Paris Saint-Germain. The Italian, one of the world’s top goalkeepers, has quickly established himself as Pep Guardiola’s first-choice, starting against Manchester United, Napoli, and Arsenal.
As a result, Trafford has fallen down the pecking order, now competing with Stefan Ortega for domestic cup appearances rather than challenging for the Premier League starting spot.
Guardiola’s comments on Trafford
Speaking ahead of City’s Carabao Cup third-round clash with Huddersfield Town, Guardiola confirmed Trafford would return to the starting XI but stopped short of guaranteeing his long-term future as City’s first-choice goalkeeper.
“Unbelievable. [With] Xabi Mancisidor, training better than ever. He’s a fantastic keeper. And with me, all the second keepers always play a lot of games. And there will not be an exception. When he’s so safe, so confident, so young, he will learn with Gigio [Donnarumma] and in the future, we’ll see what happens.”
When pressed further on whether Trafford could eventually become City’s No.1, Guardiola responded: “I’m not a genius to anticipate what will happen in the future, I’m sorry to tell you. I would like to tell you but I don’t know.”
Future in the balance
While Guardiola’s words suggest Trafford will continue to feature in cup competitions, they also highlight the uncertainty surrounding his long-term role. With the 2026 FIFA World Cup on the horizon, regular first-team football will be crucial for Trafford if he is to maintain his international prospects.
A potential loan move as early as the January transfer window could be explored if Trafford pushes for more consistent minutes, and interest is expected from both Premier League and European clubs given his distribution skills, age, and proven ability at top-flight level.
For now, Trafford remains part of Guardiola’s plans, but Donnarumma’s arrival has shifted the dynamic significantly, leaving the question of whether the young Englishman will ever fully establish himself as Manchester City’s No.1 wide open.
FAQ
- Why is James Trafford’s Manchester City future in doubt?
The arrival of Gianluigi Donnarumma has pushed him down the pecking order, raising questions about his long-term role at the club.
- Will Trafford play for Manchester City this season?
Yes, Pep Guardiola confirmed he will feature in domestic cup matches, including the Carabao Cup.
- Could Trafford leave in January?
A loan move is possible if he seeks regular first-team football to protect his international chances.
- Which clubs could be interested in Trafford?
Premier League and European clubs are expected to monitor his situation, given his experience and potential.
Conclusion
James Trafford’s Manchester City journey is at a crossroads. While Pep Guardiola continues to value him within the squad, the arrival of Gianluigi Donnarumma complicates his progression to becoming City’s first-choice goalkeeper. With international ambitions on the line, Trafford’s next career steps may become clearer in the months ahead, with January shaping up as a pivotal moment for his future.
