Guardiola asks for explanations from Howard Webb after Wolves penalty controversy
Pep Guardiola has called for clarity from PGMOL chief Howard Webb following a controversial refereeing decision during Manchester City’s 2-0 Premier League victory over Wolves at the Etihad Stadium.
The incident in question saw referee Farai Hallam, on his Premier League debut, refuse to award Manchester City a penalty despite being sent to the pitchside monitor by VAR. Hallam judged that Yerson Mosquera’s arm was in a natural position when the ball struck it inside the penalty area.
Referee stands by VAR decision
After reviewing the footage, Hallam chose to stick with his original on-field decision, a call that divided opinion. Wolves head coach Rob Edwards backed the referee, praising his resolve.
“At the time it seemed like he was in a natural position,” Edwards told Sky Sports. “He showed good character and strength to stick with his decision on the pitch.”
Guardiola’s frustration made clear
Guardiola, however, took a markedly different stance when addressing the media after the match. The Manchester City manager suggested the decision set a worrying precedent and demanded transparency from officiating authorities.
“The referee made a huge debut, now everybody will know him,” Guardiola said. “I think it’s the first time they go to the TV and disallowed what is a ‘normal’ position of the arms.”
The City boss went on to directly reference PGMOL chief Howard Webb, insisting that an explanation should be provided immediately rather than delayed.
“I’m pretty sure Howard Webb tomorrow is going to appear in the media to explain why it’s not a penalty and what he did against Manchester United,” Guardiola continued. “Like it was the first time he had done it because there was a little bit of doubt.”
Links to recent refereeing decisions
Guardiola also drew comparisons with previous controversial incidents involving his side, including Jeremy Doku’s unavailability for the Champions League trip to Norway following a challenge by Diogo Dalot that went unpunished domestically.
“That’s why Jeremy could not play in Norway – for the action from Dalot. But it is OK,” Guardiola added. “I am waiting tomorrow. Do not wait for Wednesday. We have Champions League, we are busy.”
Pressure on officiating bodies
The comments place further scrutiny on Premier League officiating at a time when VAR decisions continue to dominate post-match discussions. Guardiola’s pointed remarks underline a growing frustration among managers over perceived inconsistencies in handball interpretations.
Conclusion
Pep Guardiola’s demand for an immediate explanation from Howard Webb highlights the ongoing tension between clubs and match officials over VAR interventions. While Manchester City secured all three points against Wolves, the manager’s reaction suggests that concerns over refereeing standards remain unresolved and could continue to shape the narrative around City’s season.
FAQ
- What was the controversial decision?
Manchester City were denied a penalty after referee Farai Hallam ruled that Yerson Mosquera’s arm was in a natural position, despite a VAR review.
- Who is Farai Hallam?
Farai Hallam is a referee making his debut in the Premier League.
- What did Pep Guardiola say?
Guardiola criticised the decision and called on PGMOL chief Howard Webb to publicly explain why the penalty was not awarded.
- Did Wolves agree with the decision?
Yes, Wolves manager Rob Edwards supported the referee’s call, stating it appeared to be a natural arm position.
- Why did Guardiola mention Jeremy Doku?
Guardiola referenced a previous refereeing incident involving Diogo Dalot that resulted in Doku missing a Champions League match, highlighting perceived inconsistency.
